Design for Function, Not Just Manufacturability
Design for Manufacturing (DFM) is a critical consideration in developing precision metal components. The objective is straightforward: optimize component designs to achieve functional requirements while minimizing manufacturing complexity, cost, and production risk.
For engineers accustomed to designing parts for stamping, laser cutting, CNC machining, or wire EDM, conventional manufacturing constraints often influence design decisions long before a prototype is produced.
Photo Chemical Machining (PCM), also known as photochemical etching, offers a different approach.
By selectively removing metal through a controlled chemical etching process, PCM enables complex geometries, intricate features, and precision components without the mechanical stresses associated with conventional metalworking.
Understanding PCM’s capabilities early in the design process can open opportunities to improve both component performance and manufacturing economics.
1. Start with Material Selection and Thickness
PCM is particularly well suited for thin-gauge metal components, typically less than 0.040 inches thick, although thicker materials may also be processed depending on the alloy and design requirements.
Common PCM-compatible materials include:
- Stainless steels for filtration, fluid control, and thermal management.
- Copper and copper alloys for electronic and thermal applications.
- Nickel alloys for aerospace, energy, and high-temperature environments.
- Kovar and Alloy 42 for microelectronic packaging.
- Aluminum alloys for lightweight precision components, where suitable etching processes are available.
Material composition, temper, thickness, and surface condition influence etching behavior and dimensional consistency.
DFM recommendation: Engage your PCM supplier before finalizing material specifications. Alternative alloys or thicknesses may improve manufacturability without compromising performance.
2. Understand Etching Geometry and Dimensional Limits
Unlike stamping or laser cutting, PCM removes material chemically, generally from both sides of the metal sheet.
Because etching proceeds laterally as well as through the material thickness, designers must account for undercut—the sideways removal of metal beneath the photoresist.
Important considerations include:
- Minimum feature size: Small openings, slots, and narrow webs depend on material thickness and etching characteristics.
- Dimensional tolerances: Achievable tolerances depend on thickness, alloy, geometry, and process controls.
- Corner geometry: Etched internal corners naturally develop radii rather than perfectly sharp profiles.
- Feature spacing: Closely spaced openings require sufficient remaining metal to maintain structural integrity.
A useful preliminary guideline is that minimum through-etched openings and web widths may approach the material thickness, depending on the application. This is not a universal design limit; actual capabilities should be confirmed with the manufacturer.
DFM recommendation: Specify critical dimensions and functional requirements rather than applying unnecessarily restrictive tolerances to every feature.
3. Exploit Partial-Etch Capabilities
One of PCM’s most valuable design advantages is its ability to create both through-etched and partially etched features within the same component.
Partial etching enables engineers to incorporate:
- Microchannels for liquid cooling and fluid distribution.
- Recesses for electronic packaging and component positioning.
- Fold lines and controlled bending features.
- Identification markings and traceability information.
- Surface patterns for filtration, flow control, and thermal applications.
These features can often be produced without additional machining operations.
For example, a stainless steel flow distribution plate may incorporate through-holes, shallow channels, and alignment features within a single etched component.
DFM recommendation: Consider whether features normally requiring secondary machining can be incorporated into the original PCM artwork.
4. Design for Burr-Free, Stress-Free Fabrication
Mechanical fabrication processes can introduce burrs, residual stresses, distortion, or heat-affected zones.
PCM avoids cutting forces and localized thermal input, making it especially attractive for thin, delicate, or highly detailed components.
Applications include precision filtration screens, electronic lead frames, fuel cell bipolar plates, heat exchanger foils, and aerospace components.
Because PCM does not rely on hard tooling or mechanical cutting, intricate patterns can be manufactured without the tool wear associated with conventional machining.
DFM recommendation: Evaluate PCM when component flatness, edge quality, or freedom from mechanically induced distortion is important.
5. Consider Prototyping and Production Economics
PCM uses digitally generated phototooling rather than expensive hard dies.
This provides several advantages during product development:
- Relatively low tooling investment.
- Rapid design modifications.
- Economical prototype iterations.
- Multiple component designs produced from common sheet materials.
- A practical transition from prototypes to production quantities.
For components with complex geometries, PCM economics can be especially attractive because manufacturing time is influenced more by material, thickness, and processing requirements than by the number of individual features.
DFM recommendation: Compare total manufacturing costs—including tooling, secondary operations, inspection, and engineering changes—rather than unit fabrication cost alone.
6. Collaborate with Your PCM Supplier Early
The greatest DFM benefits are often realized before a component design is finalized.
Engineers should provide their PCM supplier with material requirements, thickness, CAD drawings, critical dimensions, expected production quantities, and functional performance requirements.
An experienced PCM manufacturer can identify opportunities to simplify geometry, improve tolerances, reduce cost, and eliminate unnecessary secondary operations.
The Bottom Line: Make PCM Part of Your DFM Toolkit
Photo Chemical Machining should not be viewed simply as an alternative way to manufacture an existing design. Its greatest value emerges when engineers understand its unique capabilities and incorporate them into the original design.
For thin-gauge precision metal components, PCM offers an attractive combination of geometric complexity, design flexibility, low tooling costs, and freedom from mechanical and thermal cutting stresses.
Conard Corporation specializes in Photo Chemical Machining of precision metal components for demanding industrial applications. Our team works with engineers and designers to evaluate component requirements, improve manufacturability, and identify opportunities where PCM can deliver meaningful technical and economic advantages.
Have a precision metal component under development?
Visit www.conardcorp.com to discuss your design with Conard’s engineering team and discover whether Photo Chemical Machining is the right manufacturing solution.
For More Information:
Contact
"*" indicates required fields
